protein-containing
foods such as meat, fish, milk and many vegetables.
Why
is MSG used?
MSG is a flavor enhancer that has been used
effectively to bring out the best taste in foods. MSG enhances
the taste of food by emphasizing its natural flavors. Many researchers
also believe that MSG imparts a fifth taste sensation independent
of the four basic tastes of sweet, sour, salty and bitter. They
call this taste "umami." This taste of glutamate is
to tomatoes, cheese and meat what sweetness is to sugar, sourness
is to lemons, saltiness is to anchovies, and bitterness is to
coffee.
How
does MSG work?
Glutamate is found in all protein-containing
foods, but only enhances flavors when it appears in its "free"
form, not bound together with other amino acids in protein.
"Free" glutamate levels in foods vary greatly, but
are high in foods such as tomatoes, mushrooms, and parmesan
cheese. These foods have been known for their distinctive flavoring
for many centuries.
When MSG is added to foods, it
provides a similar flavoring function as the "free"
glutamate that occurs naturally in these foods.
What
is MSG made of?
In the early part of this century, MSG was extracted from seaweed
and other plant sources to be used in foods much like other
spices or extracts. Today, MSG is made from starch, corn sugar
or molasses from sugar cane or sugar beets. MSG is produced
by a fermentation process similar to that used for making products
such as beer, vinegar and yogurt.
How is MSG handled
by the body?
The human body does not treat glutamate which
is added to foods any differently than the naturally occurring
glutamate found in food. For instance, the body doesn't distinguish
between free glutamate from tomatoes or added glutamate in tomato
sauce.
Does MSG improve flavors
in all foods?
MSG enhances many but not all food flavors.
It works well with a variety of foods including meats, poultry,
seafood, and many vegetables. It is used to enhance the flavor
of some soups, stews, and meat-based sauces. MSG harmonizes
well with salty and sour tastes, but does little for sweet foods
such as cakes, sweet doughs or confectionery items.
Is MSG safe?
Yes, MSG is one of the most extensively researched
substances in the food supply. International scientific evaluations
have been undertaken over many years, involving hundreds of
studies. Governments worldwide, including the U.S. Food and
Drug Administration, the Joint Expert Committee on Food Additives
(JECFA) of the United Nations Food and Agricultural Organization
and the World Health Organization, and the Scientific Committee
for Food of the European Community support the safety of MSG
as used in foods. It is possible that some people might experience
a mild sensitivity to MSG.
In 1988,
JECFA evaluated the scientific research on MSG and concluded,
"On the basis of available data (chemical, biochemical,
toxicological and other) the total dietary intake of glutamates
arising from their use at the levels necessary to achieve the
desired technological effect and from their acceptable background
in food do not, in the opinion of the Committee, represent a
hazard to health."
In 1995
U.S. Food and Drug Administration, after lengthy evaluation,
had further endorsed the safety of MSG for human consumption.
Is MSG safe for children?
Yes. As stated by the European Community's
Scientific Committee for Food in June 1991, "Infants, including
prematures, have been shown to metabolize glutamate as efficiently
as adults and therefore do not display any special susceptibility
to elevated oral intakes of glutamate."
Free
glutamate is abundant in human breast milk, which contains approximately
10 times more free glutamate than cow's milk. Researchers have
shown that newborn infants are able to detect the taste of free
glutamate.
Are some people allergic
to MSG?
It is possible that some people might be
sensitive to MSG, just as to many other foods and food ingredients.
In its 1988 report, the Joint FAO/WHO Expert Committee stated
"Studies have failed to demonstrate that MSG is the causal
agent in provoking the full range of symptoms of Chinese restaurant
syndrome."
The Food
and Drug Administration investigates all complaints in the United
States about possible adverse reactions to MSG. It has concluded
that there is some evidence that mild reactions to MSG may occur
in a small portion of the population, but it is "not aware
of any scientific evidence that establishes that monosodium
glutamate causes particularly severe adverse reactions, or that
reactions to low doses of monosodium glutamate occur and are
life threatening." (Federal Register June 21, 1991).
Can people react to
naturally occurring MSG?
If individuals experience hypersensitivity
reactions to added MSG, it would be expected that they would
experience similar symptoms from foods containing comparable
quantities of "free" glutamate, such as tomatoes and
mushrooms. Although such reactions are sometimes associated
with Chinese food, there are few reports of reactions to Italian
foods such as pizza or spaghetti that often have higher amounts
of "free" glutamate.
How can I tell if
MSG is added to foods?
By FDA regulation, all foods with added MSG
must list the ingredient on the label as monosodium glutamate.
Is MSG "hidden"
under other names on the label?
Glutamate is a natural component
of many foods such as tomatoes and parmesan cheese, as well
as food ingredients such as hydrolyzed vegetable protein (HVP)
and yeast extract.
Currently,
FDA does not require the natural glutamate component of foods
or ingredients to be listed separately on the label. However,
in a backgrounder on MSG published in October 1991, FDA stated
it will propose that the phrase "(Contains glutamate)"
be added to the label for HVP products that contain significant
amounts of glutamate. The agency noted that its decision to
make this change does not result from any health concern about
MSG's safety.
Is MSG high in sodium?
MSG contains only one-third the amount of sodium as salt (13
percent vs. 40 percent) and is used at much lower levels. MSG
can be used in many foods to reduce the total amount of sodium
by 20-40 percent, while maintaining an acceptable flavor.
How is MSG used in
the home?
If you buy MSG in the grocery store, you will find suggested
uses on the container label. MSG is generally added to foods
before or during cooking. As a general guideline, about half
a teaspoon per pound of meat or four to six servings of vegetables
should be sufficient. Once the proper amount is used, adding
more contributes little to food flavors, although it is not
a safety concern.
How much MSG do people
consume?
The glutamate added to foods for flavor represents only a small
fraction of the total amount of glutamate consumed in the average
daily diet. The average person consumes about 10 grams of bound
glutamate and 1 gram of free glutamate from daily meals. In
contrast, the added intake in the United States of glutamate
from MSG usually is less than 1 gram per day.
The human body creates about 50 grams of free glutamate daily
for use as a vital component of metabolism.
Is there anything
MSG does not do for food?
MSG does not "cover up" bad-tasting food or make up
for inept cooking. It does not allow a cook to substitute low-quality
for high-quality ingredients in a recipe, and does not tenderize
meat. All it does is make good food taste better.
How can I tell if
I'm sensitive to MSG?
The only way for physicians to determine whether someone is
truly allergic or hypersensitive to food ingredient is through
double-blind, placebo-controlled studies. These studies are
used to compare a patient's reaction to the ingredient in question
(MSG in this case) with his reaction to another substance (a
placebo) known not to cause reactions. It's also important that
neither the patient nor doctor know which substance is being
tested, to avoid the power of suggestion in stimulating reactions.
For more
information or questions about your personal health, contact
a physician or certified food allergist. It's important that
individuals don't ignore medical symptoms in the belief that
they're allergic to food ingredients, when such symptoms might
be related to a serious condition.
|